Outsourcing Payroll Processing: When It Makes Sense and What It Costs

Outsourcing Payroll Processing: When It Makes Sense and What It Costs

From tracking employees’ working hours to calculating deductions and processing payments, managing payroll is no less than an uphill battle for a growing business. As the team expands into different departments, these tasks become difficult to manage alongside other business operations.

A better way to solve this is by payroll outsourcing to a service provider. This means you outsource your payroll to a third party that handles employee payments. This third party may also handle your taxes, pay stubs, and payroll reports.

However, it is not always the best option for every business. The right decision depends on your team size, budget, payroll complexity, and how much control you want over payroll.

Let’s look at what payroll processing outsourcing covers, what it costs, and how to decide whether it makes sense for your business.

What Outsourced Payroll Covers

What Outsourced Payroll Covers

Outsourcing your payroll means handing some or all of your payroll responsibilities off to a third party. This depends on your provider and the package you choose.

Some providers offer a basic payroll service, including calculating pay and producing pay stubs. Full-service providers can also calculate taxes, submit payroll information, handle direct deposit, and produce end-of-year documents.

Here are the tasks commonly included in outsourced payroll services.

Wage and salary calculations: The provider will calculate employees’ wages based on their salary, hourly rate, approved hours worked, overtime, bonuses, and other income.

Tax calculations: Depending on your agreement, the provider will calculate the amount of payroll tax to be withheld and prepare and submit payroll tax forms. Some providers will also pay the payroll tax on your behalf.

Pay stub generation: Employees will receive a pay stub showing how much they earned, what was deducted from their pay, and their net pay. You can send it via email or the employee portal.

Direct deposit: Many providers let you set up direct deposit so your employees’ wages are deposited into their bank accounts on the agreed pay date.

Some packages will not include all these services, and some may charge premium rates for year-end procedures, out-of-cycle payroll, onboarding new staff, and additional reporting.

Ask for a clear breakdown of services included and what will incur additional charges. Although the monthly rate may seem low, if regular tasks incur additional charges, it may not be the most cost-effective solution for you.

What Stays Your Responsibility

By outsourcing your payroll tasks, you will reduce your team’s workload; however, you remain responsible for providing accurate data. When you use a payroll provider, they will work with the data you provide. If your employee data or approved hours contain inaccuracies, you could make incorrect payments.

Your business should continue to oversee several important tasks:

  • Your team must provide accurate information on staff salaries, taxes, banking, classifications, and any new hires or departures. Provide any changes promptly so they can be included in the next payroll run.

  • Ensure that someone in your business reviews regular time, overtime, authorized leave, and other attendance information before processing payroll to prevent employees from being paid more or less than they should be.

  • Ensure you have enough funds to pay employees, taxes, and other payroll deductions. Even if the payroll provider processes payments, your business must still pay on time.

  • Review the payroll figures before approving each payroll run to ensure no hours are missing, no deductions are unexpected, no pay rates are incorrect, and total payroll costs show no strange fluctuations. By regularly reviewing the reports, you can quickly find any errors.

  • While your provider may handle tax calculations and submissions, you may still have key legal obligations as a business. For example, in the US, the IRS states that employers are generally responsible for paying their employees’ federal employment taxes, even if they use a third-party payroll service. See the IRS guidance on outsourcing your payroll and third-party payers.

  • The payroll will include personal data such as addresses, tax, and bank details. Ensure they are protected with access controls and a response plan.

The goal is to eliminate day-to-day payroll activities while ensuring you have insight into your employees’ pay, taxes, and business costs.

What It Costs

The cost of payroll outsourcing depends on how many employees you have, how often you pay them, what services you need, and how complex your payroll is. You can expect to pay a flat monthly rate, an hourly rate, or a combination of both.

A basic payroll package will include calculating wages and generating pay stubs. A more advanced package will include tax submissions, direct deposit, end-of-year documentation, and employee assistance. If your business has multiple locations, different pay schedules, commission, or complex overtime rules, it may be best to choose a more advanced package.

The main factors affecting the price include:

Size of the workforce: Providers may require payment based on the number of employees. The more employees you add, the more records and payments you’ll need to process, and the more your monthly fee may rise.

Payroll frequency: If a business pays employees weekly, it may need to run more payrolls than if it pays monthly. Some offer a fixed number of runs and charge extra for additional processing.

Payroll complexity: This can involve overtime, employee classifications, bonuses or benefits, various deductions, and multiple locations. Check whether the quoted cost covers your specific payroll needs.

Extra charges: Setup fees, software integrations, off-cycle payments, special reports, and year-end services may be charged in addition to the base fee. Do not sign with a provider without obtaining a complete fee schedule.

How to Estimate Your Payroll Outsourcing Cost

How to Estimate Your Payroll Outsourcing Cost

If a provider charges you a $50 monthly base fee plus $8 per employee, then using their service would cost around:

  • Monthly base fee: $50 to access the provider’s payroll service.
  • Employee charges: 25 employees × $8 = $200.
  • Estimated monthly total: $250, before any additional fees or taxes that may apply.

Note: This is just an example, and the actual price can vary depending on the provider, location, and package you select.

Also factor in your employees’ time when comparing this to your current payroll costs. This could include time spent calculating, keeping records, maintaining the software, training, and fixing errors.

In-House vs Outsourced Payroll: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Whether you want to keep payroll in-house or outsource depends on how your business works. Keeping it in-house gives you more control over the process, while outsourcing means you hand agreed tasks to a third party. Neither option is automatically better for every business.

image

If your business has experienced staff, simple payroll processes, and plenty of time to get payroll right, an in-house payroll may be a good fit. It can also be ideal for businesses with frequent payroll changes or those that prefer to keep employee information in their internal system.

If payroll takes up too much of your staff’s time, makes it hard to keep track of tax requirements, or you want support without hiring more payroll staff, outsourcing may be the best choice. But you should consider the cost of their services, how quickly they work, and whether they can integrate with your systems.

Another option is to use payroll software within your business. This gives you full control of your payroll by allowing your team to collate employee data, calculate pay and generate reports. This can provide a good middle-ground for cost, control and convenience.

Feeding Hours From Time Tracking

Feeding Hours From Time Tracking

Accurate payroll depends on accurate timesheet data. If you record hours worked in different software than your payroll system, you’ll need manual data entry. This adds extra steps and increases the chance of errors.

If an employee worked 44 hours in a week but only 40 hours were added to their payroll, they might get paid less than they should if no one catches it before payday. This could also happen with overtime, approved time off, and shift changes not being logged.

By integrating your time-tracking software with payroll, you can reduce manual data entry and ensure accurate employee payments. When choosing a provider or system, look for features that will provide:

  • Correct hour logging: Staff should be able to log their normal hours, overtime, and leave consistently. This provides a solid foundation for payroll personnel to calculate pay.
  • Timesheet approval: Managers should be able to approve hours before payroll. An approval step helps spot missing entries, odd totals, and inaccurate overtime claims.
  • Accurate data transfer: Ensure approved hours automatically transfer to the payroll system, or, if they don’t, have staff upload files manually. An integration can save time, but only if it integrates with your existing tools.
  • Error checks and corrections: The system should make it easy to identify atypical entries, correct timesheets, and track a history of changes. This enables your team to know why the payroll value has been changed.

If you’re outsourcing payroll, ask the provider whether they’re compatible with your time-tracking system. Find out what information will automatically transfer, what your team will need to check, and how any changes can be made to your payroll.

Signs It’s Time to Outsource

There is no fixed employee count at which outsourcing becomes necessary. For example, a company with 15 employees and a complicated payroll might need outside help sooner than a company with 50 employees and a simple payroll.

Instead of focusing only on the number of employees, consider the effort required in the payroll process and whether it is reliable.

  • Payroll is time-consuming: If the finance or HR team spends several hours each pay period gathering timesheets, verifying payroll, and preparing paychecks, outsourcing could free up time for other projects. Compare the provider’s fee versus the number of hours that your team could save.
  • Your payroll depends on one employee: If payroll cannot be completed when a designated employee is absent, your process may be too dependent on one person. You should have access to records and approvals, but an external provider may offer extra support and documented procedures.
  • Errors occur frequently: If you see errors often, such as in wages, deductions, overtime, or employee records, you may need more tools or expertise to improve your process. Before outsourcing, identify the root causes of these mistakes and how an outsourcing provider would help prevent them.
  • Your employees are increasing: Adding more workers, opening new store locations, or adjusting pay structures can complicate payroll. If you don’t want to grow your staff right away, you can outsource to manage the extra workload.
  • Your actual payroll costs are unclear: Software costs don’t reveal the total cost of in-house payroll. Staff time, training, record-keeping, and corrections also add to it. If you can’t calculate these costs, first review your current process and then compare it to an outsourcing quote.

Make the Right Choice for Your Business

Outsourcing payroll can reduce the number of menial tasks you need to do. It can also give your business access to experts and make payroll easier to manage as your company grows. If your process is simple and your team can manage it efficiently, you may prefer to keep payroll in-house or use payroll software.

Before you choose, review your current costs, compare provider fees, and clarify roles. No matter what option you choose, your time recording must be accurate, and your approval process must be consistent.

Make payment management easier for your business. Sign up for free.

The platform is free to use. Host Merchant Services earns its revenue through payment processing.